Researchers used the NIRSpec instrument on the James Webb Space Telescope to observe the interstellar comet 3I/ATLAS on December 22 and 23, 2025, on the section of its orbit leading away from the Sun. They measured a deuterium-to-hydrogen ratio of (0.98 ± 0.06) percent in its water; for carbon dioxide and carbon monoxide, they determined carbon isotope ratios of 141 to 191 and 123 to 172, respectively, using several plausible baseline models. The authors interpret these extreme values as evidence of formation at temperatures of about 30 kelvin or below in a relatively metal-poor environment.
The third known visitor from outside
According to NASA, 3I/ATLAS is the third known object from outside our solar system to have been discovered while passing through our cosmic neighborhood. The NASA-funded ATLAS survey telescope in Rio Hurtado, Chile, reported its first observations to the Minor Planet Center on July 1, 2025, and astronomers classified the comet as interstellar because of the hyperbolic shape of its orbit. Martin Cordiner, who according to Sky & Telescope led a team studying the comet with the James Webb Space Telescope, and his team received permission to interrupt Webb's planned observing schedule and study the comet with NIRSpec, according to the European Space Agency. Its ancient ice had already turned into a bright gas coma by the time of the observations in December 2025.
Methane with a notably high deuterium level
A second study, published online in Nature Astronomy on October 23, 2026, and led by Nathan Roth of NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center, found a deuterium-to-hydrogen ratio of about 3.2 percent in the methane of 3I/ATLAS, as t3n reported. According to the researchers, this value is at least a factor of 1.4 higher than any other direct measurement of organic molecules in the solar system, with the closest being the value of 1.5 percent for organic radicals in the Orgueil meteorite. In comet 67P, the only other comet in which deuterated methane has been detected so far, the value was about 13 times lower, according to t3n. The methane value was also around three times as high as the ratio previously measured in the water of 3I/ATLAS. The study itself assesses the elevated value as consistent with the formation of the ices in a cold, metal-poor interstellar or protostellar environment under intense cosmic radiation.
How certain is the origin
Direct comparative measurements of the deuterium-to-hydrogen ratio of methane outside the solar system are still largely lacking, which is why the authors of the methane study instead used the deuteration of another hydrocarbon, cyclopropenylidene, as a proxy. In the researchers' own assessment, it is uncertain whether theoretical models of star formation or disk chemistry can reproduce the measured methane ratio at all; ideally, this should be confirmed by new chemical models. Even the age of 11 to 12 billion years applies under the assumption that the comet comes from the nearby galactic disk, and whether it originated in the thick disk or the statistically more likely thin disk remains an open question, according to the study. The authors themselves describe the exact time and place of formation and the comet's path through the galaxy as still highly uncertain. A third study, now published, of the dust of 3I/ATLAS found predominantly amorphous rather than crystalline silicates, as typically found in solar system comets. It sees this as evidence of formation in a distant part of its home system from material resembling the interstellar medium. As a less likely alternative, the same authors suggest that originally crystalline silicates could have become amorphous during the journey lasting billions of years. Teresa Paneque-Carreño, co-leader of a new study and an astronomy professor at the University of Michigan, interpreted the ratio measured in that study as evidence of a colder formation environment with less radiation than during the formation of our solar system.
The analysis was still incomplete in mid-2026
According to Sky & Telescope on June 22, 2026, analysis of the interstellar visitor was still incomplete at the time of publication, and astronomers were continuing to analyze the data collected during its brief visit to the solar system to test the origin scenario. According to the first study, the measurements of water and carbon so far point to a very cold, metal-poor formation environment; according to the methane study, the methane value is consistent with such an environment under intense cosmic irradiation, while the dust analysis points more toward formation in a distant part of the home system; according to the first study dated June 22, 2026, the age and exact place of origin of 3I/ATLAS could not be determined unambiguously.
